The Pros and Cons of Open Shelving vs. Closed Cabinets

When it comes to kitchen design, storage is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make. Beyond functionality, your choice also sets the tone for the entire space. The debate often comes down to two options: open shelving or closed cabinets. Both have their appeal, but they also come with trade-offs. Let’s explore the pros and cons of each to help you decide what’s right for your kitchen!

Open Shelving

Pros

• Airy and Spacious Feel
  Open shelves make a kitchen feel larger, brighter, and less boxed in.

• Quick Access
  Everyday essentials like plates, mugs, and spices are always within reach.

• Style on Display
  Shelves give you the chance to show off your favorite dishware, cookbooks, or décor.

• Budget-Friendly
  In many cases, shelving costs less than full cabinetry, making it an attractive option for remodels.

Cons

• Clutter Risk
  Without careful organization, open shelves can look messy fast.

• Maintenance
  Items are more exposed to dust, grease, and cooking splatters.

• Limited Storage
  Bulky appliances or less-attractive items don’t fit well in open storage.

• Casual Vibe
  This look doesn’t suit every design style, especially more formal or traditional kitchens.

Closed Cabinets

Pros

• Hidden Storage
  Everything from snacks to small appliances stays tucked out of sight.

• Streamlined Look
  Cabinets create a clean, uncluttered backdrop for the rest of your kitchen design.

• Protection
  Doors shield contents from dust, grease, and sunlight.

• Design Versatility
  Cabinets work with nearly any style—from sleek modern to cozy farmhouse.

Cons

• Heavier Appearance
  Solid doors can make smaller kitchens feel more enclosed.

• Higher Cost
  Quality cabinetry is often one of the most expensive aspects of a remodel.

• Accessibility
  Grabbing something from a cabinet isn’t as quick as reaching for an open shelf.

• Less Decorative Impact
  With everything hidden, you miss the chance to showcase favorite pieces.

The Best of Both Worlds: A Hybrid Approach

For many homeowners, the solution isn’t choosing one or the other—it’s blending both. Open shelving on a single wall or above the sink can add personality, while closed cabinets keep the bulk of storage practical and hidden. This balance delivers the best of both worlds: style and function.

–

Ready to reimagine your kitchen? Schedule a free consultation with our team today! For inspiration and practical advice, don’t miss our blog Open Shelving vs. Traditional Cabinets: Which Is Right for Your Kitchen? We break down the pros and cons of each option to help you decide what works best for your lifestyle, design goals, and budget—so you can create a kitchen that’s both beautiful and functional.

Back